Gill Hill Rd, partly in New Lisbon and partly in Pittsfield

The Gill home, once known as Pittsfield's haunted house.
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/48428200

PDFs about Mark Gill and this quote from a book.

Copied from an old book in the 1970’s per verbatim, by Cynthia Smith
"In the early 19th century, a road running West from near New Lisbon, connected the Butternut Creek Valley with the Wharton Creek via the Aldrich and Card creeks. It was one of the first roads to be laid over the fast rising hill and down toward the “Ball School House” on the present “Morris – Ketchum – Edmeston” improved road. This early road accommodated many ox teams and team hauling operations. Farmers and drovers necessarily drove their flocks of turkeys, geese, sheep and herds of horses and cattle overland to the Catskill and Albany merchants. This was before the coming of the railroads. Peddlers and dealers returning home with money received for their animal sale were often robbed, murdered and disposed of in the nearby forests. “Gill Hill” developed and carried a reputation of having such lawless people. There is little question regarding some such happenings. Complete facts as to the extent of such lawless acts, have been hard to check with living authorities. It seemed to be common report that Mark Gill, a resident of this hill section, entertained peddlers and other travelers carrying much ready cash. These people were seen going there and were never seen afterward.
It was reported that “Hat” Goodspeed, a neighbor, called and found Mrs. Gill lying in bed with her throat cut. She could not speak, being nearly dead. She faintly pointed to an open razor and then to her husband Mark as he made his way across the lots.
Many woods covered this hill section and only two homes stood nearby.
The full extent of such things will never be fully known. The Gills seemed to have had a very bad name and seemed to avoid the law. Some have said that he was a member of the “James? Loomis Gang.” His farm is now state land and the old hill route is abandoned. Mark’s grave is in the middle of the woods beside his second wife, Martha. Mark died in 1885, his second wife, Martha, in 1858. Elsewhere in the woods, is the grave of his first wife Lucinda, also two sons, who died in 1834 and 1840."
From the description here, it appears there are two cemeteries. I found the foundation of the house a few years back. The graves are supposed to be much further up the hill.